Randi Zuckerberg said earlier this week, “Anonymity on the Internet has to go away” during a discussion about cyber bullying. “People behave a lot better when they have their real names down,I think people hide behind anonymity and they feel like they can say whatever they want behind closed doors.”
What is it that motivates this. For starters the argument by the lady above holds good. However, lets look at what benefits this gives us.
First, it prevents users from vulgarities and prowlers and ending up getting unwanted e-attention.
Second, it allows for multiple identities creation, something like creating multiple emails for sorting out their subscription emails from their friends’ email.
and lastly, it safeguards from identity thefts and deliberate hacking, while allowing for sort of indirect whistle blowing.
She makes a valid argument that people do tend to misuse the veil of anonymity they get while being part of some email or social network provider. Profanity and slander are well disguised under userid’s like ‘shortmail’, ‘cooldude’, ‘smartgal’ and many others. While these are the obvious ones, there are a plethora of identities that do not identify the people themselves or come under an honest profile per se.
Randi’s argument that this would change however holds no water.
Remember few years back when Lok Sabha TV started up.(For non starters, this live telecasts proceedings from the house.). Our honourable MP’s put on a decent show initially when this started, giving all the feeling that it was for the better. Look at the later scenario. Does it indicate any thing that behaviour is improved or things have improved in the people representatives behaviour? I disagree. Anyone doubting it should look up the adjournments and vandalism witnessed by lots of TV viewers across the country.
Second, face to face is the highest possible way of eliminating anonymity. Do our streets reflect a decent behaviour in that perspect. Who hasn’t jumped a red light or jaywalked. The pinnacle was a street murder caught on traffic cams in TN few days back.
Does eliminating internet anonymity serve a real purpose, given the above counter argument I believe not. However, this is one thing that should not be dismissed so quickly. May be there is a better way of countering it than I can think of. Good luck to those who have a vision.